Explore Forums Discussions Camera Equipment SLR/DSLR Lenses Zoom Lense Advice

Viewing 5 reply threads

Zoom Lense Advice

  • Author
    Posts
    • Nickiew
      Participant
      Post count: 2

      Hi all

      Im looking for some advice, im currently in the position where I want to buy a Zoom lense for wildlife photography.

      My wife has the Sigma 150-600 which is an amazing lens.

      My camera is a Canon 77D.

      Ive been looking around on the second hand market and seen the following

      Sigma 150-500

      Sigma 150-600

      Tamron 150-600

      So I suppose ive kind off narrowed it down to the above 3 lenses. But here is my question
      Is the money difference worth the difference of the 150-500 or 150-600
      How good is the 150-500 as ive read some people struggle with the autofocus on this lens
      The ive chatted to people who says the Tamron takes more Sharper images.

      Would you say its worth spending the extra money and getting a 150-600 ?

      Any advice would be appreciated

      Thanks
      Nickie

    • elsahoffmann
      Moderator
      Post count: 3720

      I am not a Canon user – but if you are looking at the Sigma 150-600 – make sure you are looking at the Sport version (not the contemporary version. There is a substantial difference in price.

    • Jeffreysa
      Participant
      Post count: 287

      You really should consider the Canon 100-400 MK2. It is a fantastic lens IMHO.

    • SimonDP
      Moderator
      Post count: 2155

      What is your budget? If I have to rate all lenses in terms of quality, the list would be (note that I have used and done reviews on just about all of these lenses, see my website for reviews)
      1. Canon 100-400 Mk2
      2. Sigma 150-600 Sport (very close to above in optical terms, slightly slower AF in lower light, but 200mm reach extra. Using 100-400/2 with a 1.4x levels it between these two.
      3. Tamron 150-600 G2…still needs f8 or 7.1 for better quality images, and better AF than Mk1
      4 Sigma 150-600 Contemporary and Sigma 150-500 OS, 150-500 wins on price but loses 100mm, can be had for bargain buy
      5. Tamron 150-600 Mk1…..not a lens I am fond of, needs f8 for sharp images, poor AF compared to others.
      My 2c worth…

    • Nickiew
      Participant
      Post count: 2

      @SimonDP 298492 wrote:

      What is your budget? If I have to rate all lenses in terms of quality, the list would be (note that I have used and done reviews on just about all of these lenses, see my website for reviews)
      1. Canon 100-400 Mk2
      2. Sigma 150-600 Sport (very close to above in optical terms, slightly slower AF in lower light, but 200mm reach extra. Using 100-400/2 with a 1.4x levels it between these two.
      3. Tamron 150-600 G2…still needs f8 or 7.1 for better quality images, and better AF than Mk1
      4 Sigma 150-600 Contemporary and Sigma 150-500 OS, 150-500 wins on price but loses 100mm, can be had for bargain buy
      5. Tamron 150-600 Mk1…..not a lens I am fond of, needs f8 for sharp images, poor AF compared to others.
      My 2c worth…

      Thanks Simon

      Budget is around 8-12k
      Hence the reason why im looking at the Sigma or Tamron

      Would love the Canon 100-400 Mk2 seen quote a few reviews on it and with the usability and weight it think its a much easier lens to use for handheld but the price is just a bit high for me at the moment.

    • SimonDP
      Moderator
      Post count: 2155

      In that case…..Sigma 150-600 Contemporary, ot Canon 100-400 Mk1. Both can be had for 9k+

Viewing 5 reply threads

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.Log In